Clearwater FL’s Premier Independent
Insurance Agency

We’ve been proudly serving all of Florida for 20+ years!

Start Quotes Here in Seconds

We bring a unique approach to insurance

All Services & Products  

We bring a unique approach to insurance

Here are just some of the products we offer. Check our products tab for a full list of products.

Auto Insurance Classic & Exotic Auto Home & Rental Boat & Watercraft Business Insurance

Carriers We Represent

View Our Carriers  

Carriers We Represent

Bay Area Insurance Shop only represents the highest quality insurance carriers.

Travelers Mercury Progressive Safeco Infinity Kemper

We’re a local team of professionals here to help

We are a locally owned independent agency located in Clearwater, FL. Our belief is that you treat people how you want to be treated, regardless of whether they are a customer or not. If you live in the Clearwater area, or any other part of Florida and searching for a better customer experience, price, or product, Bay Area Insurance Shop would love the opportunity to earn your business.

I would 100% recommend Bay Area Insurance! We recently moved our insurance to them from another agency and they've gone above and beyond for us on several occasions.

I would 100% recommend Bay Area Insurance! We recently moved our insurance to them from another agency and they've gone above and beyond for us on several occasions.

I would 100% recommend Bay Area Insurance! We recently moved our insurance to them from another agency and they've gone above and beyond for us on several occasions.

I would 100% recommend Bay Area Insurance! We recently moved our insurance to them from another agency and they've gone above and beyond for us on several occasions.

Your Clearwater Florida Insurance Agent

We bring a unique approach to insurance.

Start Quotes Here

Call Email Claims Payments